24th Pizza & Meatballs

Not gonna lie, the big MEATBALLS sign on the front of the building is what drew us in, but then after looking at pizza pics on their Google page, we knew we had to come back. Giant pizza and a large Caesar salad fed the four of us more than comfortably. Oh, and we got the spicy meatball to share/try. It was all so tasty we finished it all and rolled ourselves back to our car. Guys working inside were super nice too. Highly recommend!

I ordered off Postmates and forgot to add a second Nonna’s Special. (Click to read further.) Postmastes told me I needed to contact the store to add a second item. When I called the store to add a second they told me that they could not do that and I had to do it in the app or cancel and order again. I told them the app says it will charge me for the cancelled order since they started making it. They told me they had not started making it and when the person I was on the phone with asked for confirmation, that person in the background dismissively told them the order was not being prepared and to tell me I was “wrong”. The person I was on the phone with did not tell me I was “wrong” but did convey the message. Anyways, Postmates charged me because the restaurant did in fact accept the order and Postmates basically told me to kick rocks when I tried to contact them about it. I did place and receive the second order. The food was OK. Meatballs and Garlic knots were pretty good. The pasta was over cooked well beyond al dente. Overall I am disappointed in the lackluster food quality after being treated dismissively and lied to. I hope the $24 the business gets to keep after accepting my order and telling me to cancel it and place another one helps keep the business afloat.